● November 2026 edition

An independent guide for people who travel alone
Bank Street, a residential street in Greenwich Village, Manhattan
United StatesNew York
Rue Saint-Viateur seen from avenue de l'Esplanade in Montréal's Mile End
CanadaMontréal
vs

The verdict

Montréal wins for 16 of 16 traveller profiles. Check your own row though: for some people the other city is still the right call.

Who wins, profile by profile

Travelling asNew YorkMontréalBetter
Anyone5880Montréal
Solo woman6482Montréal
Solo man5678Montréal
Gay man6385Montréal
Lesbian woman6585Montréal
Bi/pan person6385Montréal
Trans person6089Montréal
Non-binary person6089Montréal
Over 505782Montréal
First time6083Montréal
On a budget5275Montréal
High end6484Montréal
Digital nomad6078Montréal
After a breakup6080Montréal
On my own6086Montréal
Single parent5583Montréal

The nine components

Safety
18 · 92
Safety for women
83 · 92
LGBTQ+ inclusivity
79 · 99
Trans recognition
55 · 95
Social life
54 · 50
Ease
95 · 95
Cost for one
37 · 67
Nightlife and events
80 · 90
Singles demographics
56 · 55

Money and seasons

Mid budget per day~152 €~96 €
Best seasonMay–JunMay–Jun
MonthNew YorkMontréal
Jan5°-4°
Feb7°-2°
Mar11°4°
Apr16°11°
May21°19°
Jun27°24°
Jul30°27°
Aug28°26°
Sept25°22°
Oct19°15°
Nov12°6°
Dec7°-1°

New York

Yes, if your budget can take it: the subway runs 24/7, volunteer greeters will show you around for free, and New York State tops Spartacus's state-by-state index. The problem is price. A dorm bed averages about $43 a night and a cheap meal runs $28, so travelers on a tight budget need to plan where every dollar goes.

Read the guide →

Montréal

Yes, especially between May and October, and if you want an easy first city in North America. Night buses fill the gap after the metro, central hostels have women-only rooms and the queer Village is two stops from downtown. The catch is a long, hard winter and a bill that creeps up because many prices are shown before tax.

Read the guide →