

The verdict
Montréal wins for 16 of 16 traveller profiles. Check your own row though: for some people the other city is still the right call.
Who wins, profile by profile
| Travelling as | New York | Montréal | Better |
|---|---|---|---|
| Anyone | 58 | 80 | Montréal |
| Solo woman | 64 | 82 | Montréal |
| Solo man | 56 | 78 | Montréal |
| Gay man | 63 | 85 | Montréal |
| Lesbian woman | 65 | 85 | Montréal |
| Bi/pan person | 63 | 85 | Montréal |
| Trans person | 60 | 89 | Montréal |
| Non-binary person | 60 | 89 | Montréal |
| Over 50 | 57 | 82 | Montréal |
| First time | 60 | 83 | Montréal |
| On a budget | 52 | 75 | Montréal |
| High end | 64 | 84 | Montréal |
| Digital nomad | 60 | 78 | Montréal |
| After a breakup | 60 | 80 | Montréal |
| On my own | 60 | 86 | Montréal |
| Single parent | 55 | 83 | Montréal |
The nine components
- Safety
- 18 · 92
- Safety for women
- 83 · 92
- LGBTQ+ inclusivity
- 79 · 99
- Trans recognition
- 55 · 95
- Social life
- 54 · 50
- Ease
- 95 · 95
- Cost for one
- 37 · 67
- Nightlife and events
- 80 · 90
- Singles demographics
- 56 · 55
Money and seasons
| Mid budget per day | ~152 € | ~96 € |
|---|---|---|
| Best season | May–Jun | May–Jun |
| Month | New York | Montréal |
|---|---|---|
| Jan | 5° | -4° |
| Feb | 7° | -2° |
| Mar | 11° | 4° |
| Apr | 16° | 11° |
| May | 21° | 19° |
| Jun | 27° | 24° |
| Jul | 30° | 27° |
| Aug | 28° | 26° |
| Sept | 25° | 22° |
| Oct | 19° | 15° |
| Nov | 12° | 6° |
| Dec | 7° | -1° |
New York
Yes, if your budget can take it: the subway runs 24/7, volunteer greeters will show you around for free, and New York State tops Spartacus's state-by-state index. The problem is price. A dorm bed averages about $43 a night and a cheap meal runs $28, so travelers on a tight budget need to plan where every dollar goes.
Read the guide →Montréal
Yes, especially between May and October, and if you want an easy first city in North America. Night buses fill the gap after the metro, central hostels have women-only rooms and the queer Village is two stops from downtown. The catch is a long, hard winter and a bill that creeps up because many prices are shown before tax.
Read the guide →